5 results for aunt jemima collectables. Save this search. Shipping to: 23917. Shop on eBay. Brand New. $20.00. or Best Offer. Sponsored.Item Description. 10.5” tall “Mammy” figural cookie jar and 10.25” tall “Cooky” jar glazed china by Pearl China. c. late 1940s-1950s. “Mammy” has name in 22 karat gold lettering, “Cooky” has same with additional outfit accents. Lt. wear to buttons. Both have 22 karat gold “Pearl” logo markings on undersides.Vintage Mammy With Cauliflower Cookie Jar Black Cookie Jar Kitchenware Kitchen Ware. Sold ... $ 85.94 Original Price $85.94 (25% off) ...The value of a McCoy Cookie Jar is dependent on the condition, the age, and the rarity of that specific piece. Generally speaking, the basic shaped/colored McCoy Cookie Jars will sell for up to $50 USD, the less common shaped/colored jars for up to $100 USD, and the rare shaped/colored jars sell for up to $500 USD.Manufacturer of stoneware art pottery from 1910 to 1990. Historical information, email discussion list, online store. Racist objects, created as propaganda tools during the Jim Crow era, reflect ugly stereotypes about black people. Yet some people see nostalgia, not dehumanization, in the memorabilia. The mammy...New cookie jars marked McCoy have been made since the mid-1990s. New vases, wall pockets and other shapes marked McCoy have been increasingly common in the secondary market. The new McCoy marks appear not only on copies of McCoy products but on copies of pieces originally made by other collectible potteries such as Shawnee and Hull.We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us.Home/Auctions/Online Only - Fantastic Single Estate Auction Antiques and Collectibles /Pearl Black Americana Mammy Porcelain Pottery Cookie Jar. Prev LotThis ceramic Mammy cookie jar was made ca 1943 by the Mosaic Tile Co. It has sold for as much as $600 in 2005. Other sales have been more in the $300-400 range recently.Collectible McCoy - Vintage Cookie Jar - Ceramic Antique Stove Cookie Jar - Vintage Decor (545) $ 69.00. Add to Favorites One Spooky Mawmaw Halloween PNG, Sublimation Design Downloads ... Mammy Digital 300 DPI Image for Sublimation Design, instant download design with flowers, Cute PNG Clip art for t shirt, mug, pillowVintage Brush McCoy Pottery Cookie Jar Cow with Winking Cat W10 USA VryGd+-Exc. $134.95. Free shipping. Cookie jars ideas. This is this a RARE Aunt Jemima (or Mammy) cookie jar. This cookie jar was made by the Mosaic Tile Company and is the only known cookie jar to have been made by this company. The design was patented by Kenneth Gale in 1943. What is interesting about this cookie jar is that these were not made as.Vintage Cookie Jar | Ransburg Cookie Jar | Vintage Kitchen Decor | Flower Vase | Black Table Centerpiece | Country Kitchen Decor | Cottage (594) $ 89.00. Add to Favorites Vintage Abingdon shell vase #506 yellow blue green white (242) $ 8.95. Add to Favorites Vintage Little Bo peep cookie jar - Abingdon pottery - rare Nursery Rhyme - ceramic ...Brayton Laguna also made cookie jars. They enjoy a strong secondary market among cookie jar collectors. Early Brayton Laguna dinnerware sets came in colors such as silky black, chartreuse, eggplant, old gold, lettuce green, jade green, burnt orange, strawberry pink, rose, white, and lemon yellow. Brayton Laguna was one of the first California ...McCoyPottery.Com Pottery Viewer. Mammy - Originally made with lettering. Mark. Mark #2. Date Produced. Produced in 1944-47. Description. White dress with green trim, red cap. Originally made with lettering, "Dem Cookies shor am good," fr. Nov 21, 2017 · This ceramic Mammy cookie jar was made ca 1943 by the Mosaic Tile Co. It has sold for as much as $600 in 2005. Other sales have been more in the $300-400 range recently. Welcome to the McCoy Pottery Online's Cookie Jar Index. The following list is comprised of McCoy Cookie Jars dating from the Late 30's to Present day. Each Cookie Jar is listed …The biggest Jar Collection. The biggest Jar Collection. Collector Cookie Jars ...Six to eight years ago, cookie jars such as this one in great condition sold in the $125-to-$150 range at auction, but that price has dropped by half to two-thirds. Because of its condition, the ...Feb 16, 2019 - Explore Donna Gallagher's board "Mammy cookie jar McCoy" on Pinterest. See more ideas about cookie jars, cookie jars vintage, jar._____ NEGATHA PETERSON MAMMY COOKIE JAR ERWIN POTTERY MARRIED(MISMATCHED) SET: JULY BOTTOM, SPRING MARCH/APRIL TOP Description: THIS IS A BEAUTIFUL NEGATHA PETERSON MARRIED COOKIE JAR, T IS NO NICK OR CHIPS ON THIS JAR. ... Collector’s Guide To Art Deco 2nd Edition Values …Jul 17, 2022 - Explore Shirley Shaver's board "AUNT JEMIMA COLLECTIBLES", followed by 376 people on Pinterest. See more ideas about aunt jemima cookie jar, aunt jemima, cookie jars vintage. Check out our mccoy cookie jar aunt jemima selection for the very best in unique or custom, handmade pieces from our shops. ... Sale Price $54.00 $ 54.00 $ 60.00 ...19 feb 2012 ... We saw 33 McCoy mammy jars, including many obvious fakes, listed on eBay. Checking completed sales, few sold. Top sale was $164.95. Q: Do my old ...The top is marked E26G and the bottom is marked E27G Our Mosaic Mammy cookie jar in a soft blue dress is a lovely recreation of the famous Mosaic Tile Design. The original patent for what is commonly called the Mosaic Tile Mammy was issued in 1943 to Kenneth Gale in Zanesville, Ohio.Collectible Bunny Mammy, artist teddy bunny, teddy bear, stuffed toys, interior doll. (250) $320.00. FREE shipping. Collectible M&M Vintage Cookie Jars and Candy Jars in Excellent Condition! Your Choice of 14 to Pick From! (2.3k) $14.00. An example is ‘The Mammy and Aunt Jemima’ cookie jar by McCoy pottery. Many critics argue it’s a cookie jar brand rooted in racism. The Mammy line went through several rebrands and mold changes, including the words ‘Dem Cookies’ to just ‘Cookies’ between the 1940s. The 5 most valuable cookie jars. McCoy Multicolor Fox Squirrel Jar Oct 23, 2017 · Antique stores sell items like this, a replica of a jar depicting the Mammy stereotype. (Photo by Angelica Cabral/Cronkite News) MESA – Visitors to antique shops on Main Street in Mesa will see stores crammed with primarily benign American memorabilia. A 19th century record player, a vintage 1990s Barbie, or a campaign button promoting ... An example is ‘The Mammy and Aunt Jemima’ cookie jar by McCoy pottery. Many critics argue it’s a cookie jar brand rooted in racism. The Mammy line went through several rebrands and mold changes, including the words ‘Dem Cookies’ to just ‘Cookies’ between the 1940s. The 5 most valuable cookie jars. McCoy Multicolor Fox Squirrel Jar110 Results for Mccoy Mammy Cookie Jars - For Sale Classifieds. Sort by: $225. mccoy cookie jar mammy blue. Used. No chips or cracks. San Antonio, FL. ». Collectibles. mccoy cookie jar mammy blue. Used.VINTAGE LARGE COW COOKIE JAR HOLSTEIN COW LARGE BLACK AND WHITE COUNTRY KITCHEN. Opens in a new window or tab. Pre-Owned. $79.95. slickbritches (666) 98.7%. or Best Offer +$27.90 shipping. derosnopS. Vintage Bean Pot Cherries Black Ceramic Cookie Jar Mccoy Pottery Handles. Opens in a new window or tab. Pre-Owned.Ardco Lugene’s Harvest Fruit Shaped Ceramic Cookie Jar or Canister Dish with Lid. $25. Avon President's Powder Blue Floral Cookie Jar. $35 $55. West Elm Recycled Glass and Cork Spice Rack. $39 $45. Rae Dunn Blue Polka Dot Butter Dish White Ceramic SMEAR Farmhouse Style Kitchen. $14.Mar 23, 2016 - Explore Diane Goodin's board "Memories of Mamma Cookie Jar", followed by 366 people on Pinterest. See more ideas about cookie jars, jar, cookie jars vintage.1930s Nelson Mccoy Pottery Leaves & Berry Jardiniere Planter. $40.00. 1 bid. $14.55 shipping. 14h 6m.Collectible McCoy - Vintage Cookie Jar - Ceramic Antique Stove Cookie Jar - Vintage Decor (545) $ 69.00. Add to Favorites One Spooky Mawmaw Halloween PNG, Sublimation Design Downloads ... Mammy Digital 300 DPI Image for Sublimation Design, instant download design with flowers, Cute PNG Clip art for t shirt, mug, pillowOriginal Vintage Aunt Jemima Mccoy Cookie Jar, Est. Value 995. Pricing & History. Sold for. ... Aunt Jemima Mammy Black American Cookie Jar With McCoy Mark On Bottom. Mammy Aunt Jemima McCoy Vintage Cookie Jar. Aunt Jemima Cookie Jar Mccoy. Black Americana Aunt Jemima Cookie Jar, McCoy.Collectibles. Up for your consideration is an extremely rare black mammy cookie jar. Paint is still in amazing original condition. It measures 11" tall x 6.5" wide. Please view all the pictures carefully and let me know if you have…. 1 month ago on ebay.com. $50.Mar 18, 2020 · Some cookie jars are especially rare, and these cookie jars are generally more valuable. The astronaut cookie jar, for example is rare and regularly sells for around $500 in good condition. The McCoy Mammy jar, also known as the Aunt Jemima cookie jar, is another example of one that is rare. Even in damaged condition, one of these sold for ... Because of its condition, the jar belonging to B.C. might not sell if it were offered, but for insurance purposes, she should value her piece in the $40-to-$50 range.This mammy cookie jar evokes memories of our loving grand moms. Being a very special one, it will fetch you good dollars as it is priced at $250. 2. Vintage McCoy Horse Drawn Stagecoach Cookie Jar. Brand: McCoy Year: 1940 Price: $254. Vintage McCoy Horse Drawn Stagecoach Cookie Jar. This McCoy cookie jar comes with a very rare design. It’s an ... Because of its condition, the jar belonging to B.C. might not sell if it were offered, but for insurance purposes, she should value her piece in the $40-to-$50 range.Check out our mammy cookie jar selection for the very best in unique or custom, handmade pieces from our cookie jars shops.McCoy Pottery Cookie Jar Originally made with lettering. Where McCoy Lovers Come Together ... Mammy- Originally made with lettering. Mark. Mark #2. Date Produced. Produced in 1944-47. Description: White dress with green trim, red cap. Originally made with lettering, "Dem Cookies shor am good," fr: Collector Value . Next | Back | Buy This Item ...Oct 10, 2023 · Sold Date. Source eBay. From our own collection we offer a wonderful NEGATHA PETERSON (Erwin Pottery) VALENTINE'S DAY MAMMY COOKIE JAR. This is one of the eight holiday-themed cookie jars famed Blue Ridge artist Negatha Peterson produced from her Erwin, TN studio and pottery shop. This jar is decorated in her …Adding to our Black Americana collection, this wonderful Mammy cookie jar was distributed by the National Silver Company in the late 1940s / early 1950s. According to the Illustrated Value Guide to Cookie Jars, Book II, the National Silver Company 'was another distributor that did not manufacture any of the products they sold.Cinderella Mugsie Goldielocks and Goldilux Wilbur Pig Cobalt Rooster Image Credit Identify Your Pattern Because there were so many McCoy cookie jars made, it helps to identify the pattern of the cookie jar you have. Then you can decide whether your piece is valuable. To do this, look up the jar on a list of known McCoy pottery cookie jar patterns.View sold price and similar items: Brayton Laguna ''Mammy'' cookie jar from Clars Auction Gallery on January 6, 0111 9:30 AM PST.23 oct 2017 ... Antique store owners selling Mammy figures and other African-American ... On a recent day, he had a Mammy cookie jar and figure in his store.Results 1 - 20 of 20 ... Check out our mammy cookie jar selection for the very best in unique or custom, handmade pieces from our cookie jars shops.McCoy Pottery Cookie Jars. A century of Pottery. ... Read More . McCoyPottery.Com Pottery Viewer. Mammy with Cauliflowers- hand decorated, basic white. Mark. McCoy USA. Date Produced. Produced in 1939. Description: Made in a limited edition. Extremely Rare. Typically found with worn cold paint. Collector Value . $1000.00 - $1200.00. Next | Back ...Vintage Hull LITTLE RED RIDING HOOD Cookie Jar #135889 Made In USA 1940s Nice. $99.95. $13.05 shipping.McCoy Pottery only made two black mammy cookie jars. Both jars are widely reproduced which has caused values to come down quite a bit over the last few ...Sold Date. Source eBay. For your consideration is a Vintage "Mammy Cookie Jar", made by the Mosaic Tile Company of Zanesville, Ohio. The cookie jar is a very light blue in color and 13" tall by 8" wide at the base and has a 3 3/4" by 5 3/4" wide opening w the jar opens. I believe the cookie jar to have been made in the 1940's.Sep 29, 2023 · Sold Date. Source eBay. For your consideration is a Vintage "Mammy Cookie Jar", made by the Mosaic Tile Company of Zanesville, Ohio. The cookie jar is a very light blue in color and 13" tall by 8" wide at the base and has a 3 3/4" by 5 3/4" wide opening w the jar opens. I believe the cookie jar to have been made in the 1940's. Oct 10, 2023 · Sold Date. Source eBay. From our own collection we offer a wonderful NEGATHA PETERSON (Erwin Pottery) VALENTINE'S DAY MAMMY COOKIE JAR. This is one of the eight holiday-themed cookie jars famed Blue Ridge artist Negatha Peterson produced from her Erwin, TN studio and pottery shop. This jar is decorated in her …Mccoy Mammy With Cauliflower Cookie Jar, Reproduction. circa-1970.Shipped with USPS Priority Mail.A Good depiction of Black Americana. No chips or cracks. Copied from an original that is taller and would cost $1000.00 plus. I've enjoyed this piece in my kitchen for 30 years. Great conversation piece.Price includes the shipping cost.Sep 13, 2020 · This is a 1940s McCoy Mammy cookie jar valued at $180 to $225. ... Doris-drm925 hello there. we have a McCoy cookie jar that we cannot find the value of. hope you can help. enclosed are photos..she is 11 inches tall. thank you al dowell ...9.25” tall Mammy jar and 10” tall “Sambo The Chef” cookie jar. Both by National Silver Co. c. 1940s. Mammy has incised “USA” on underside, Chef has incised “USA N.S. Co.” Mammy has some paint wear to over-the-glaze paint accent on shoes and polka dots on apron. Light paint wear to red lips. VF. Chef has paint wear to lips, teeth ...24 mar 2017 ... Aunt Jemima Cookie jar how much is she worth. 1.8K views · 6 years ago ...more. Kevin Sumpter. 11. Subscribe. 11 subscribers. 17. Share.Find prices for MAMMY COOKIE JAR to help when appraising. Instant price guides to discover the market value for MAMMY COOKIE JAR. Research the worth of your items …Jun 15, 2005 · It showed exclusive replicas of antique Mammy figures: cookie jars, salt and paper shakers, and tea towels decorated with pictures of pickanniny- like children eating watermelon.BUY, SELL & VALUE Brayton Laguna. - FIND TODAY's SELECTED Brayton Laguna offered FOR SALE, BEST OFFER and Auction... plus expert appraisal, valuation, FREE sale advice and brokerage services, a FREE price/value guide, FREE sale prices, values, wish list and more. Selling and valuing online since 1997. Buy, sell and value in over 150+ …Sep 20, 2021 · McCoy Cauliflower Mammy Cookie Jar USA Black Americana 11" Tall. ANTIQUE McCOY MAMMY WITH CAULIFLOWER COOKIE JAR - NICE! LOOK! ... The Collector’s Guide To Harker Pottery U.S.A. Identification And Value. Collection Of Japanese Art From A Museum In The New England States. Architecture Ceramics, June 1977.The biggest Jar Collection. The biggest Jar Collection. Collector Cookie Jars ...Cookie jars with brightly painted designs or amusing figural shapes became popular in the mid-1930s. Many companies made them and collectors search for cookie jars either by design or by maker’s name. Brush Pottery Company made the first ceramic cookie jar and Nelson McCoy made the best-known cookie jars in the 1930s. Listed here are examples …Hi, After my research your vintage Gilner Googly-eyed Aunt Jemima's Cookie Jar & Salt & Pepper Shaker set w/bail handle w/wire grips also came with a covered sugar dates to the mid 1950's and has a value as a set in today's market at auction in good condition $50.00 + to excellent condition $85.00 + depending on the collector or consumer.27 dic 2011 ... ... mammy cookie jar in today's question. They could not compete with ... This yellow-dressed Mosaic Tile cookie jar mentioned above is worth up ...How much is my mammy cookie jar worth? Retail value for the old jar with worn paint is under $200. Auction results show the jars selling for $40 to $160. Remember that when buying, dealers pay half or less. We saw 33 McCoy mammy jars, including many obvious fakes, listed on eBay.Weller pottery Mammy cookie jar showing Mammy holding a large watermelon; image credit on full record. Find Current Values for your Antiques! Cookie Jar ...Large Salty has paint flake on foot & couple paint flakes on face. The item “Vintage 1940s Cooky and Mammy Cookie Jar set by Pearl China Gold Gilt Americana” is in sale since Saturday, February 1, 2020. This item is in the category “Collectibles\Kitchen & Home\Kitchenware\Cookie Jars\Vintage (Pre-1970)”. The seller is “musky50″ and ...BUY, SELL & VALUE Brayton Laguna. - FIND TODAY's SELECTED Brayton Laguna offered FOR SALE, BEST OFFER and Auction... plus expert appraisal, valuation, FREE sale advice and brokerage services, a FREE price/value guide, FREE sale prices, values, wish list and more. Selling and valuing online since 1997. Buy, sell and value in over 150+ specialist ...Values: $700+ Note: The prices shown are suggested ranges only. Prices shown are a combination of book values, online auctions and cookie jar dealers. Many times bargains can be found at online auctions and at other times a bidding war can …Mammy / Aunt Jemima cookie jar was made by the Mosaic Tile Co. of Zanesville, Ohio. The company was started by Karl Langerbeck and Herman Mueller in 1894. It closed in 1967. The company's principal products were plain and ornamental tiles, but some ashtrays, bookends, and related giftwares were also made. This was the only cookie jar made by ...9.25” tall Mammy jar and 10” tall “Sambo The Chef” cookie jar. Both by National Silver Co. c. 1940s. Mammy has incised “USA” on underside, Chef has incised “USA N.S. Co.” Mammy has some paint wear to over-the-glaze paint accent on shoes and polka dots on apron. Light paint wear to red lips. VF. Chef has paint wear to lips, teeth ...BUY, SELL & VALUE Brayton Laguna. - FIND TODAY's SELECTED Brayton Laguna offered FOR SALE, BEST OFFER and Auction... plus expert appraisal, valuation, FREE sale advice and brokerage services, a FREE price/value guide, FREE sale prices, values, wish list and more. Selling and valuing online since 1997. Buy, sell and value in over 150+ specialist ...New cookie jars marked McCoy have been made since the mid-1990s. New vases, wall pockets and other shapes marked McCoy have been increasingly common in the secondary market. The new McCoy marks appear not only on copies of McCoy products but on copies of pieces originally made by other collectible potteries such as Shawnee and Hull. Today, the rarest McCoy pieces cost thousands of dollars. on eBay, for example, we found a rare McCoy cookie jar with a price tag of $3,500 attached to it. The cookie jar was followed closely by a Jardiniere selling at $950 and a flower vase selling at $895.Treasure Craft Cookie Jar - Vintage. (7) $60.00. 1. 2. Here is a selection of four-star and five-star reviews from customers who were delighted with the products they found in this category. Check out our treasure craft cookie jar selection for the very best in unique or custom, handmade pieces from our jars & containers shops.Teens Lying on Blanket Photo Print | Vintage Black Americana | 1950s Summer Best Friends Great Outdoors. (168) $9.99. FREE shipping. Vintage Black Pottery Crock with a Lid and Hand Painted Flowers. Folk Art Home Decor Pottery Accessory. (2) …Because of its condition, the jar belonging to B.C. might not sell if it were offered, but for insurance purposes, she should value her piece in the $40-to-$50 range.Shop this gift guide. Beautiful VINTAGE ORIGINAL MCCOY AUNT JEMIMA MAMMY COOKIE JAR. BLACK AMERICANA. This is an original piece, early edition of this themed McCoy cookie jar. The Aunt Jemima cookie jar by McCoy circa 1940 wears a white smock with green trim, and deep red bandana which are hand painted under the. What unscrupulous people do in their attempt to defraud buyers is, select a jar of their choice and make a mold of it, with the original mark removed, if any, and replace it with the McCoy mark. The modified mold results in a cookie jar that has a McCoy mark on it. Some unsuspecting buyers assume that the jar is authentic because it marked McCoy.
Cookie jar apothecary jar storage display jar large metal lid vintage. Wichita, KS. $500 $5,000. original hamburger helper cookie jar. Tulsa, OK. $60. Mushroom Cookie Jar. Winfield, KS. $10. Minnie Cookie Jar. Edmond, OK. $25. Glass Canisters Posh Pantry Organizing. Platte City, MO. $18. Vintage dog cookie jar.. L death note pfp
Oct 10, 2023 · Sold Date. Source eBay. From our own collection we offer a wonderful NEGATHA PETERSON (Erwin Pottery) VALENTINE'S DAY MAMMY COOKIE JAR. This is one of the eight holiday-themed cookie jars famed Blue Ridge artist Negatha Peterson produced from her Erwin, TN studio and pottery shop. This jar is decorated in her …Oct 6, 2023 · Brayton Laguna also made cookie jars. They enjoy a strong secondary market among cookie jar collectors. Early Brayton Laguna dinnerware sets came in colors such as silky black, chartreuse, eggplant, old gold, lettuce green, jade green, burnt orange, strawberry pink, rose, white, and lemon yellow. Brayton Laguna was one of the first California ... Mammy cookie jars can cost $500. Aunt Jemima and Uncle Mose salt and pepper shakers sold for $180 earlier this year at an antiques show in Fort Lauderdale. And rarer and larger pieces can command ...1 Gallon Custom Cookie Jar Personalized Cookie Jar Glass Cookie Jar Cookie Lover Gift Gift for Baker Cookie Jar Gift Gift For Mom Mother's. bittersweetlemonade. $25.50.The original mammy cookie jar is 13 1/2 inches tall and is found most often wearing a yellow dress with a turban-like head covering. This would appear to be the type that M. S. has. This yellow ...prints digital prints giclée. Beautiful VINTAGE ORIGINAL MCCOY AUNT JEMIMA MAMMY COOKIE JAR. BLACK AMERICANA. This is an original piece, early edition of this themed McCoy cookie jar. The Aunt Jemima cookie jar by McCoy circa 1940 wears a white smock with green trim, and deep red bandana which are hand painted under the.The mammy cookie jar in today's question is supposedly the product of Mosaic Tile Co. of Zanesville, Ohio. ... but if the dress is blue the price jumps to $700 or $750. But if the dress happens to ...Mccoy Mammy With Cauliflower Cookie Jar, Reproduction. circa-1970.Shipped with USPS Priority Mail.A Good depiction of Black Americana. No chips or cracks. Copied from an original that is taller and would cost $1000.00 plus. I've enjoyed this piece in my kitchen for 30 years. Great conversation piece.Price includes the shipping cost.American Bisque Jack In The Box Cookie Jar - Clown Cookie Jar - Vintage Kitchen. SwanCreekCottage. $48.99. This is an original Aunt Jemima cookie jar manufactured by MCCoy pottery. White ceramic with cold paint, red bandanna, black paint on her face and hands. The cookie jar measures 11 inches high, no chips but there is crazing and paint loss ... Retail value for the old jar with worn paint is under $200. Auction results show the jars selling for $40 to $160. Remember that when buying, dealers pay half or less. We saw 33 McCoy mammy jars ...19 feb 2012 ... We saw 33 McCoy mammy jars, including many obvious fakes, listed on eBay. Checking completed sales, few sold. Top sale was $164.95. Q: Do my old ...37 results for "Mammy Cookie Jar" Results Price and other details may vary based on product size and color. COSMOS GIFTS Fine Ceramic Dollymamas African American …23 oct 2017 ... Antique store owners selling Mammy figures and other African-American ... On a recent day, he had a Mammy cookie jar and figure in his store.Vintage Mammy cookie jar is a classic of black memorabilia, but alas this one- while marked McCoy - is a reproduction albeit with significant age but in our view not McCoy. ... so this mammy cookie jar - while it has good decorative value - is not in fact original McCoy and thus being sold as a decorative piece versus the $500+ or so an ...Find prices for MAMMY COOKIE JAR to help when appraising. Instant price guides to discover the market value for MAMMY COOKIE JAR. Research the worth of your items …3. McCoy Jack’O’Lantern from 1955 – $579. 2. McCoy Freddy the Gleep from 1974 – $2,500. 1. McCoy Multicolor Fox Squirrel Jar – $4,600. McCoy cookie jars are probably one of the most popular items among beginner antique collectors because they’re relatively cheap and can be attained without emptying your pockets. .